I analyzed the scene in which Ree
goes to Milton’s house and attempts to talk with him in order to obtain information about her
father’s whereabouts. When talking to
Milton’s wife, Ree uses the word ‘mam’ twice, which is a sign of respect, but she
cusses when she is denied the opportunity to talk to Milton, which can be
viewed as disrespect. In the beginning
of the scene Milton’s wife has her arms crossed and a stern face and by the end
of the scene Ree has the same body position, whereas Milton's wife now looks exposed and nervous.
These two observations lead to the conclusion that in the beginning of
the scene Milton’s wife holds the power and Ree is vulnerable. She has Ree’s future in her hands and the
power to say no. By the end of the scene
Ree has the control and Milton’s wife is the one who is nervous. Ree is persistent and has the ability to
cause problems. Milton’s wife is scared
of what Ree might discover. Ree is
courageous and not intimidated, this aids her in acquiring knowledge on her
father’s disappearance.
Milton’s wife calls Ree ‘child’
four times during the scene. When Ree
waits for Milton the camera pans to a statue in the yard of children
playing. These are both ironic and
symbolic. Ree being referred to as a
child is ironic because even though she is only seventeen, she takes care of her entire
family as an adult would. She holds all
the responsibility for her family and is very mature for her age, so being referred
to as a child is demeaning and does not match Ree's character at all. The statue
is symbolic because it sits in the yard of a person who holds Ree's little siblings' and mother's fate
in their hands. The children in the
statue are joyful, but Ree’s little brother and sister will not have a joyful, innocent
childhood if Milton does not reveal what has been done to Ree’s father. Ree’s motherly personality and her inner need
to protect her family push her to gain information.
Ree stops Milton’s wife from saying
no a multiple times within the scene. When she
turns her back on Ree to go inside, Ree says, “Please mam, I really, really got
to”. Later in the scene when Ree is told
she cannot talk to Milton, Ree quickly replies, “I’ll wait” and also forcefully
claims they are blood and that should be of value to Milton. She has a determined and stubborn
personality. Ree refuses to give up or
leave without the information she craves.
This scene does a terrific job demonstrating how Ree’s personality helps
her to collect insight on her father.
This is a well detailed post Emily. Funny, as I was specifically going to write about this exact same seen, since it was such a build up in the movie and clearly put her inside the snakes den. But after reading yours, I felt you offered such an extremely detailed write up, and I had sent the movie back to Netflix already, that I figured I'd better use another scene.
ReplyDeletePersistence was indeed her key, and a little stubbornness for company. This scene said a lot to me watching the film. I actually had no idea where this was going to go, good or bad. But like you wrote, I guess this was one of the best examples of showing who the real Ree was in the midst of so much obvious danger, which she also couldn't afford too much of because of the siblings. Nice post.
Thank you for the compliment! :)
ReplyDeleteGood evening Emily. I also was going to analyze the same scene in the book "Winters Bone." You did such a wonderful job I decided to choose another scene to review.
ReplyDeleteI agree that Ree is persistent and stubborn when she needs to get answers. She is the head of her family now and needs to find answers. It has all been left on her shoulders. She knows, I think, when to be respectful but then can be stubborn when she doesn't get the answer she is looking for. She has no choice in the matter now. She needs to save her family and will do whatever it takes if needed.
I completely agree Kimberly, Ree is respectful, but stubborn when the situation calls for it!
ReplyDeleteYou chose a very pivotal scene out of the movie. It is at this point that you see the determination that Ree has to protect what is hers and does not care what danger she must face. It is also interesting to see the change in body language between the beginning of the scene and the end. Milton's wife doesn't take her requests seriously until she realizes she is not a weak child and will not back down. You did a great job tearing the scene apart and finding all those little things that made it all that more significant.
ReplyDeleteYou did a really great job of analyzing this scene and pointing out a lot of details that I didn’t initially pick-up on. Your observation of the statue with the children and the significance of this with regard to Ree and her family was really insightful. I had noticed it but didn’t think much about other than it seemed really out of place where it was. It makes sense that that statue would be used in this scene as a symbol of what Ree and her siblings’ lives should be like but won’t unless Ree is able to find her father and gain her family security.
ReplyDelete